Why are my emails going to spam? A checklist

The usual reasons mail lands in the junk folder, in the order worth checking them, from authentication to content.

Mailbox providers decide between inbox and spam based on hundreds of signals, but most problems come down to a handful of causes. Work through them in this order: the first ones are quick to check and fix, the later ones take longer.

1. Authentication

Does the message pass SPF, DKIM and DMARC, with your own domain? Unauthenticated mail from a domain is the most common reason for the spam folder today, because Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft now require it. Check a received copy's Authentication-Results header.

2. Blocklists and server setup

Is your sending IP, or a domain you link to, on a blocklist? If you run your own server, does it have matching reverse DNS and send over TLS?

3. Reputation

Providers remember how recipients react to your mail. If many people mark it as spam, ignore it, or you send to many addresses that don't exist, your domain's reputation drops and all your mail suffers, including one-to-one messages. Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS show how they see you.

  • Send only to people who asked for your mail.
  • Remove addresses that bounce, and stop mailing people who haven't opened anything in months.
  • Make unsubscribing easy, including one-click unsubscribe. An unsubscribe costs you nothing; a spam complaint does.
  • Send marketing from a subdomain, so a bad campaign doesn't drag down your invoices and personal mail.

4. Content

  • Link shorteners and links to unrelated or newly registered domains.
  • A single big image with almost no text.
  • Attachments like .zip, .exe or macro-enabled Office files.
  • Link text that shows one address while the link goes to another.
  • Broken HTML, or no plain-text version at all.

Content matters less than it used to, but it tips the balance when your reputation is borderline.

5. Consistency

A new domain, a new IP, or a sudden jump in volume all look suspicious. Start small with your most engaged recipients and increase gradually. Keep the From name and address the same from one mailing to the next.