permerror (permanent error) means the receiver could not evaluate your SPF record at all. Unlike fail, it isn't
about one server: it applies to every message. DMARC treats it as an SPF failure, so all your mail then depends on DKIM alone.
The causes, most common first
- More than 10 DNS lookups. See too many DNS lookups.
- More than one SPF record on the domain. See multiple SPF records.
- More than two void lookups: includes that point to names that don't exist. See void lookups.
-
Syntax errors. Typical ones:
include: spf.example.net: a space after the colon.ip4:203.0.113.0/33: an impossible network size.v=spf1missing, misspelled (v=spf) or not at the start.- Smart quotes (“ ”) pasted from a document instead of straight quotes.
- Unknown words like
include=instead ofinclude:.
- A broken included record. If a provider's SPF record has an error, or an include points to a record that includes itself (a loop), your record inherits the permerror.
- An included domain publishes two SPF records. Also a permerror, even though it's someone else's domain.
How to fix it
- Look up your record:
dig TXT example.com +short, and check there is exactly one line starting withv=spf1. - Run it through a checker that expands includes; it will point at the part that fails.
- If the error is in a provider's record, remove that include until they fix it, or contact them.